Insulted and Injured
Last year, on the evening of March 22, I had a very strange adventure. All
that day I had been walking about the town trying to find a lodging. My old one
was very damp, and I had begun to have an ominous cough. Ever since the autumn I
had been meaning to move, but I had hung on till the spring. I had not been able
to find anything decent all day. In the first place I wanted a separate
tenement, not a room in other people's lodgings; secondly, though I could do
with one room, it must be a large one, and, of course, it had at the same time
to be as cheap as possible. I have observed that in a confined space even
thought is cramped; When I was brooding over a future novel I liked to walk up
and down the room. By the way, I always like better brooding over my works and
dreaming how they should be written than actually writing them. And this really
is not from laziness.
Why is it?
I had been feeling unwell all day, and towards sunset I felt really very ill.
Something like a fever set in. Moreover, I had been all day long on my legs and
was tired. Towards evening, just before it got dark, I was walking along the
Voznesensky Prospect. I love the March sun in Petersburg, especially at sunset,
in clear frosty weather, of course. The whole street suddenly glitters, bathed
in brilliant light. All the houses seem suddenly, as it were, to sparkle. Their
grey, yellow, and dirty- green hues for an instant lose all their gloominess, it
is as though there were a sudden clearness in one's soul, as though one were
startled, or as though someone had nudged one with his elbow.
There is a new outlook, a new train of thought.... It is wonderful what one
ray of sunshine can do for the soul of man! But the ray of sunshine had died
away; the frost grew sharper, and began to nip one's nose: the twilight
deepened; gas flared from the shops. As I reached Muller's, the confectioner's,
I suddenly stood stock-still and began staring at that side of the street, as
though I had a presentiment that something extra- ordinary was just going to
happen to me ; and at that very instant I saw, on the opposite side of the
street, the old man with his dog. I remember quite well that I felt an
unpleasant sensation clutch at my heart, and I could not myself have told what
that sensation was.
I am not a mystic. I scarcely believe in presentiments and divinings, yet I
have, as probably most people have, had some rather inexplicable experiences in
my life. For example, this old man : why was it that at that meeting with him I
had at once a presentiment that that same evening something not quite ordinary
would happen to me ? I was ill, however, and sensations in illness are almost
The old man, stooping and tapping the pavement with his stick, drew near the
confectioner's, with his slow, feeble step, moving his legs as though they were
sticks, and seeming not to bend them. I had never in my life come across such a
strange, grotesque figure, and, whenever I had met him at Muller's before, he
had always made a painful impression on me. His tall figure, his bent back, his
death-like face with the stamp of eighty years upon it, his old great-coat torn
at the seams, the battered round hat, at least twenty years old, which covered
his head - bald but for one lock of hair not grey but yellowish-white - all his
move- ments, which seemed performed, as it were, aimlessly, as though worked by
springs - no one who met him for the first time could help being struck by all
this. It really was strange to see an old man who had so outlived the natural
spar, alone, with no one to look after him, especially as he looked like a
madman who had escaped from his keepers. I was struck, too, by his extraordinary
emaciation ; he seemed scarcely to have any body, it was as though there were
nothing but skin over his bones. His large lustreless eyes, set as it were in
blue rims, always stared straight before him, never looking to one side, and
never seeing anything - of that I feel certain; though he looked at you, he
walked straight at you as though there were an empty space before him. I noticed
this several times. He had begun to make his appearance at Muller's only lately,
he was always accompanied by his dog, and no one knew where he came from. Not
one of the customers at Muller's could make up his mind to address him, nor did
he accost any of them.
"And why does he drag himself to Muller's, what is there for him to do
there?" I wondered, standing still on the opposite side of the street and gazing
fixedly at him. A sort of irritable vexation, the result of illness and fatigue,
surged up within me.
"What is he thinking about?" I went on wondering. "What is there in his head?
But does he still think of anything at all? His face is so dead that it
expresses nothing at all. And where could he have picked up that disgusting dog,
which never leaves him, as though it were an inseparable part of him, and which
is so like him?"
That wretched dog looked as though it, too, were eighty; yes, it certainly
must have been so. To begin with, it looked older than dogs ever are, and
secondly, it struck me, for some reason, the very first time I saw it, that it
could not be a dog like all others; that it was an exceptional dog; that there
must be something fantastic about it, something uncanny; that it might be a sort
of Mephistopheles in dog-form, and that its fate was in some mysterious unknown
way bound up with the fate of its master.
Looking at it you would have allowed at once that twenty years must have
elapsed since its last meal. It was as thin as a skeleton, or, which is much the
same, as its master. Almost all its hair had fallen off, and its tail hung down
between its legs as bare as a stick. Its head and long ears drooped sullenly
forward. I never in my life met such a repulsive dog. When they both walked down
the street, the master in front and the dog at his heels, its nose touched the
skirt of his coat as though glued to it. And their gait and their whole
appearance seemed almost to cry aloud at every step: "We are old, old. Oh Lord,
how old we are! " I remember too that it occurred to me once that the old man
and the dog had somehow stepped out of some page of Hoffmann illustrated by
Gavarni and were parading this world by way of walking advertisements of the
I crossed the road and followed the old man into the con- fectioner's.
In the shop the old man behaved in a very strange way, and Muller, standing
at his counter, had begun of late to make a grimace of annoyance at the entrance
of the unbidden guest. In the first place, the strange visitor never asked for
Every time he went straight to a corner by the stove and sat down in a chair
there. If the seat by the stove were occupied, after standing for some time in
bewildered perplexity before the gentleman who had taken his place, he walked
away, seeming puzzled, to the other corner by the window. There he fixed on a
chair, deliberately seated himself in it, took off his hat, put it on the floor
beside him, laid his stick by his hat, and then, sinking back into the chair, he
would remain without moving for three or four hours. He never took up a
newspaper, never uttered a single word, a single sound, and simply sat there,
staring straight before him with wide-open eyes, but with such a blank, lifeless
look in them that one might well bet he saw and heard nothing of what was going
on around him. The dog, after turning round two or three times in the same
place, lay down sullenly at his feet with its nose between his boots, heaving
deep sighs, and, stretched out full length on the floor, it too stayed without
moving the whole evening as though it bad died for the time. One might imagine
that these two creatures lay dead all day somewhere, and only at sunset came to
life again, simply to visit Muller's shop to perform some mysterious, secret
duty. After sitting for three or four hours, the old man would at last get up,
take up his hat and set off somewhere homewards. The dog too got up, and, with
drooping tail and hanging head as before, followed him mechan- ically with the
same slow step. The habitual visitors at the shop began at last to avoid the old
man in every way and would not even sit beside him, as though he gave them a
feeling of repulsion.
He noticed nothing of this.
The customers of this confectioner's shop were mostly Germans.
They gathered there from all parts of the Voznesensky Prospect, mostly heads
of shops of various sorts : carpenters, bakers, painters, hatters, saddlers, all
patriarchal people in the German sense of the word. Altogether the patriarchal
tradition was kept up at Muller's. Often the master of the shop joined some
customer of his acquaintance and sat beside him at the table, when a certain
amount of punch would be consumed. The dogs and small children of the household
would sometimes come out to see the customers too, and the latter used to fondle
both the children and the dogs. They all knew one another and all had a respect
for one another. And while the guests were absorbed in the perusal of the German
newspapers, through the door leading to the shopkeeper's rooms came the tinkling
of "Mein lieber Augustin," on a cracked piano played by the eldest daughter, a
little German miss with flaxen curls, very much like a white mouse. The waltz
was welcomed with pleasure. I used to go to Muller's at the beginning of every
month to read the Russian magazines which were taken there.
As I went in I saw that the old man was already sitting by the window, while
the dog was lying as always, stretched out at his feet. I sat down in a corner
without speaking, and inwardly asked myself why had I come here when there was
really nothing for me to do here, when I was ill and it would have been better
to make haste home to have tea and go to bed. Could I have come here simply to
gaze at this old man? I was annoyed.
"What have I to do with him?" I thought, recalling that strange, painful
sensation with which I had looked at him just before in the street. And what
were all these dull Germans to me? What was the meaning of this fantastic mood?
What was the meaning of this cheap agitation over trifles which I had noticed in
myself of late, which hindered me from living and taking a clear view of life?
One penetrating reviewer had already remarked on it in his indignant criticism
of my last novel. But though I hesitated, and deplored it, yet I remained where
I was, and meantime I was more and more overcome by illness, and I was reluctant
to leave the warm room. I took up a Frankfort paper, read a couple of lines and
dropped into a doze. The Germans did not interfere with me. They read and
smoked, and only once in half an hour or so communicated some piece of Frankfort
news to one another abruptly in an undertone, or some jest or epigram of the
renowned German wit, Saphir after which they would plunge into their reading
again with redoubled pride in their nationality.
I dozed for half an hour and was waked by a violent shiver.
It was certainly necessary to go home.
But meanwhile a drama in dumb show which was being enacted in the room
stopped me again. I have said already that as soon as the old man sat down in
his chair he would fix his eye on something and not remove it the whole evening.
It had been my fate in the past to be exposed to that meaningless, persistent,
unseeing stare. It was a very unpleasant, in fact unbearable, sensation, and I
usually changed my seat as soon as I could. At this moment the old man's victim
was a small, round, very neat little German, with a stiffly starched stand-up
collar and an unusually red face, a new visitor to the shop, a merchant from
Riga, called, as I learned afterwards, Adam Ivanitch Schultz.
He was an intimate friend of Muller's, but as yet knew nothing of the old man
or many of the customers. Sipping his punch and reading with relish the
Dorfbarbier, he suddenly raised his eyes and observed the old man's immovable
stare fixed upon him. It disconcerted him. Adam Ivanitch was a very touchy and
sensitive man, like all "superior" Germans. It seemed to him strange and
insulting that he should be stared at so un- ceremoniously. With stifled
indignation he turned his eyes away from the tactless guest, muttered something
to himself, and took refuge behind the newspaper. But within five minutes he
could not resist peeping out suspiciously from behind the paper; still the same
persistent stare, still the same meaningless scrutiny.
That time, too, Adam Ivanitch said nothing. But when the same thing was
repeated a third time he flared up and felt it incumbent upon himself to defend
his dignity and not to degrade, in the eyes of so gentlemanly a company, the
prestige of the fair town of Riga, of which he probably felt himself to be the
With an impatient gesture he flung the paper on the table, rapping it
vigorously with the stick to which the paper was fastened, and blazing with
personal dignity, and crimson with punch and amour Propre, in his turn he
fastened his little bloodshot eyes on the offensive old man. It looked as though
the two of them, the German and his assailant, were trying to overpower each
other by the magnetic force of their stares, and were waiting to see which would
be the first to be put out of countenance and drop his eyes. The rap of the
stick and the eccentric position of Adam Ivanitch drew the attention of all the
customers. All laid aside what they were doing, and with grave and speechless
curiosity watched the two opponents. The scene was becoming very comical, but
the magnetism of the little red-faced gentleman's defiant eyes was entirely
thrown away. The old man went on staring straight at the infuriated Schultz, and
absolutely failed to observe that he was the object of general curiosity; he was
as unperturbed as though he were not on earth but in the moon.
Adam Ivanitch's patience broke down at last, and he exploded.
"Why do you stare at me so intently?" he shouted in German, in a sharp,
piercing voice and with a menacing air.
But his adversary continued silent as though he did not under- stand and even
did not hear the question. Adam Ivanitch made up his mind to speak to him in
"I am asking you what for you at me are so studiously staring?" he shouted
with redoubled fury, "I am to the court well known, and you known not!" he
added, leaping up from his chair.
But the old man did not turn a hair. A murmur of indignation was heard among
the Germans. Muller himself, attracted by the uproar, came into the room. When
he found out what was the matter he imagined that the old man was deaf, and bent
down to his ear.
"Master Schultz asked you studiously not to stare at him." he said as loud as
he could, looking intently at the incomprehensible visitor.
The old man looked mechanically at Muller; his face, which had till then been
so immovable, showed traces of disturbing thought, of a sort of uneasy
agitation. He was flustered, bent down, sighing and gasping, to pick up his hat,
snatched it up together with his stick, got up from his chair, and with the
piteous smile of a beggar turned out of a seat that he has taken by mistake, he
prepared to go out of the room. In the meek and submissive haste of the poor
decrepit old man there was so much to provoke compassion, so much to wring the
heart, that the whole company, from Adam Ivanitch downward, took a different
view of the position at once. It was evident that the old man, far from being
capable of insulting anyone, realized that he might be turned out from anywhere
like a beggar.
Muller was a kind-hearted and compassionate man.
"No, no," he said, patting him on the shoulder encouragingly, "sit still.
Aber Herr Schultz asking you particularly not to look upon him. He is well known
at the court."
But the poor old man did not understand this either; he was more flustered
than ever. He stooped to pick up his hand- kerchief, a ragged old blue one that
had dropped out of his hat, and began to call his dog, which lay motionless on
the floor an seemed to be sound asleep with its nose on its paws.
"Azorka, Azorka," he mumbled in a quavering, aged voice.
Azorka did not stir.
"Azorka, Azorka," the old man repeated anxiously, and he poked the dog with
his stick. But it remained in the same position.
The stick dropped from his hands. He stooped, knelt, down, and in both hands
lifted Azorka's head. The poor dog was dead.
Unnoticed it had died at its master's feet from old age, and perhaps from
hunger too. The old man looked at it for a minute as though struck, as though he
did not understand that Azorka was dead; then bent down gently to his old
servant and friend and pressed his pale cheek to the dead face of the dog. A
minute of silence passed. We were all touched. At last the poor fellow got up.
He was very pale and trembled as though he were in a fever.
"You can have it stoffed," said the sympathetic Muller anxious to comfort him
an any way (by "stoffed" he mean stuffed). "You can have it well stoffed, Fyodor
Karlitch Kruger stoffs beautifully; Fyodor Karlitch Kruger is a master at
stoffing," repeated Muller, picking up the stick from the ground and handing it
to the old man.
"Yes, I can excellently stoff," Herr Kruger himself modestly asserted, coming
to the front.
He was a tall, lanky and virtuous German, with tangled red hair, and
spectacles on his hooked nose.
"Fyodor Karlitch Kruger has a great talent to make all sorts magnificent
stoffing, "added Muller, growing enthusiastic over his own idea.
"Yes, I have a great talent to make all sorts magnificent stoffing," Herr
Kruger repeated again. "And I will for nothing to stoff you your dog," he added
in an access of magnanimous self-sacrifice.
"No, I will you pay for to stoff it!" Adam Ivanitch Schultz cried
frantically, turning twice as red as before, glowing with magnanimity in his
turn and feeling himself the innocent cause of the misfortune.
The old man listened to all this evidently without under- standing it,
trembling all over as before.
"Vait! Drink one glass of goot cognac!" cried Muller, seeing that the
enigmatical guest was making efforts to get away.
They brought him the brandy. The old man mechanically took the glass, but his
hand trembled, and before he raised it to his lips he spilt half, and put it
back on the tray without taking a drop of it. Then with a strange, utterly
inappropriate smile he went out of the shop with rapid, uneven steps, leaving
Azorka on the floor. Everyone stood in bewilderment; exclamations were heard.
"Schwernoth! Was fur eine Geschichte ? " said the Germans, looking round-eyed
at one another.
But I rushed after the, old man. A few steps from the shop, through a gate on
the right, there is an alley, dark and narrow, shut in by huge houses. Something
told me that the old man must have turned in there. A second house was being
built here on the right hand, and was surrounded with scaffolding. The fence
round the house came almost into the middle of the alley, and planks had been
laid down to walk round the fence. In a dark corner made by the fence and the
house I found the old man.
He was sitting on the edge of the wooden pavement and held his head propped
in both hands, with his elbows on his knees. I sat down beside him.
"Listen," said I, hardly knowing how to begin. "Don't grieve over Azorka.
Come along, I'll take you home. Don't worry. I'll go for a cab at once. Where do
The old man did not answer. I could not decide what to do.
There were no passers-by in the alley. Suddenly he began clutching me by the
"Stifling!" he said, in a husky, hardly audible voice, "Stifling!"
"Let's go to your home," I cried, getting up and forcibly lifting him up. "
You'll have some tea and go to bed. . . .
I'll get a cab. I'll call a doctor.... I know a doctor. . . ."
I don't know what else I said to him. He tried to get up, but fell back again
on the ground and began muttering again in the same hoarse choking voice. I bent
down more closely and listened.
"In Vassilyevsky Island," the old man gasped. "The sixth street. The six ...
th stre ... et"
He sank into silence.
"You live in Vassilyevsky Island? But you've come wrong then. That would be
to the left, and you've come to the right.
I'll take you directly . . ."
The old man did not stir. I took his hand; the hand dropped as though it were
dead. I looked into his face, touched him - he was dead.
I felt as though it had all happened in a dream.
This incident caused me a great deal of trouble, in the course of which my
fever passed off of itself. The old man's lodging was discovered. He did not,
however, live in Vassilyevsky Island, but only a couple of paces from the spot
where he died, in Klugen's Buildings, in the fifth storey right under the roof,
in a separate flat, consisting of a tiny entry and a large low-pitched room,
with three slits by way of windows. He had lived very poorly. His furniture
consisted of a table, two chairs, and a very very old sofa as hard as a stone,
with hair sticking out of it in all directions ; and even these things turned
out to be the landlord's.
The stove had evidently not been heated for a long while, and no candles were
found either. I seriously think now that the old man went to Muller's simply to
sit in a lighted room and get warm. On the table stood an empty earthenware mug,
and a stale crust of bread lay beside it. No money was found, not a farthing.
There was not even a change of linen in which to bury him; someone gave his own
shirt for the purpose. It was clear that he could not have lived like that,
quite isolated, and no doubt someone must have visited him from time to time. In
the table drawer they found his passport. The dead man turned out to be of
foreign birth, though a Russian subject. His name was Jeremy Smith, and he was a
mechanical engineer, seventy-eight years old. There were two books lying on the
table, a short geography and the New Testament in the Russian translation,
pencil-marked in the margin and scored by the finger-nail. These books I took
for myself. The landlord and the other tenants were questioned - they all knew
scarcely anything about him. There were numbers of tenants in the building,
almost all artisans or German women who let lodgings with board and attendance.
The superintendent of the block, a superior man, was also unable to say much
about the former tenant, except that the lodging was let at six roubles a month,
that the deceased had lived in it for four months, but had not paid a farthing,
for the last two, so that he would have had to turn him out. The question was
asked whether anyone used to come to see him, but no one could give a
satisfactory answer about this. It was a big block, lots of people would be
coming to such a Noah's Ark, there was no remembering all of them. The porter,
who had been employed for five years in the flats and probably could have given
some information, had gone home to his native village on a visit a fortnight
before, leaving in his place his nephew, a young fellow who did not yet know
half the tenants by sight. I don't know for certain how all these inquiries
ended at last, but finally the old man was buried. In the course of those days,
though I had many things to look after, I had been to Vassilyevsky Island, to
Sixth Street, and laughed at myself when I arrived there. What could I see in
Sixth Street but an ordinary row of houses ? But why, I wondered, did the old
man talk of Sixth Street and Vassilyevsky Island when he was dying? Was he
delirious? I looked at Smith's deserted lodging, and I liked it I took it for
myself. The chief point about it was that it was large, though very low-pitched,
so much so that at first I thought I should knock my head against the ceiling.
But I soon got used to it.
Nothing better could be found for six roubles a month. The independence of it
tempted me. All I still had to do was to arrange for some sort of service, for I
could not live entirely without a servant. The porter undertook meanwhile to
come in once a day to do what was absolutely necessary. And who knows, thought
I, perhaps someone will come to inquire for the old man But five days passed
after his death, and no one had yet come.