GERMINAL
PART IV
CHAPTER I
ON that Monday the Hennebeaus had invited the
Grégoires and their daughter Cécile
to lunch. They had formed their plans: on rising
from table, Paul Négrel was to take the
ladies to a mine, Saint-Thomas, which had been
luxuriously reinstalled. But this was only an
amiable pretext; this party was an invention of
Madame Hennebeau's to hasten the marriage of
Cécile and Paul.
Suddenly, on this very Monday, at four o'clock in
the morning, the strike broke out. When, on the
1st of December, the Company had adopted the new
wage system, the miners remained calm. At the end
of the fortnight not one made the least protest on
pay-day. Everybody, from the manager down to the
last overseer, considered the tariff as accepted;
and great was their surprise in the morning at
this declaration of war, made with a tactical
unity which seemed to indicate energetic
leadership.
At five o'clock Dansaert woke M. Hennebeau to
inform him that not a single man had gone down at
the Voreux. The settlement of the
Deux-Cent-Quarante, which he had passed through,
was sleeping deeply, with closed windows and
doors. And as soon as the manager had jumped out
of bed, his eyes still swollen with sleep, he was
overwhelmed. Every quarter of an hour messengers
came in, and dispatches fell on his desk as thick
as hail. At first he hoped that the revolt was
limited to the Voreux; but the news became more
serious every minute. There was the Mirou, the
Crévacoeur, the Madeleine, where only the
grooms had appeared; the Victoire and
Feutry-Cantel, the two best disciplined pits,
where the men had been reduced by a third;
Saint-Thomas alone numbered all its people, and
seemed to be outside the movement. Up to nine
o'clock he dictated dispatches, telegraphing in
all directions, to the prefect of Lille, to the
directors of the Company, warning the authorities
and asking for orders. He had sent Négrel
to go round the neighbouring pits to obtain
precise information.
Suddenly M. Hennebeau recollected the lunch; and
he was about to send the coachman to tell the
Grégoires that the party had been put off,
when a certain hesitation and lack of will stopped
him--the man who in a few brief phrases had just
made military preparations for a field of battle.
He went up to Madame Hennebeau, whose hair had
just been done by her lady's maid, in her
dressing-room.
"Ah! they are on strike," she said
quietly, when he had told her. "Well, what
has that to do with us? We are not going to leave
off eating, I suppose?"
And she was obstinate; it was vain to tell her
that the lunch would be disturbed, and that the
visit to Saint-Thomas could not take place. She
found an answer to everything. Why lose a lunch
that was already cooking? And as to visiting the
pit, they could give that up afterwards if the
walk was really imprudent.
"Besides," she added, when the maid had
gone out, "you know that I am anxious to
receive these good people. This marriage ought to
affect you more than the follies of your men. I
want to have it, don't contradict me."
He looked at her, agitated by a slight trembling,
and the hard firm face of the man of discipline
expressed the secret grief of a wounded heart.
She had remained with naked shoulders, already
over-mature, but still imposing and desirable,
with the broad bust of a Ceres gilded by the
autumn. For a moment he felt a brutal desire to
seize her, and to roll his head between the
breasts she was exposing in this warm room, which
exhibited the private luxury of a sensual woman
and had about it an irritating perfume of musk,
but he recoiled; for ten years they had occupied
separate rooms.
"Good!" he said, leaving her. "Do
not make any alterations."
M. Hennebeau had been born in the Ardennes. In
his early life he had undergone the hardships of a
poor boy thrown as an orphan on the Paris streets.
After having painfully followed the courses of the
École des Mines, at the age of twenty-four
he had gone to the Grand'Combe as engineer to the
Sainte-Barbe mine. Three years later he became
divisional engineer in the Pas-de-Calais, at the
Marles mines. It was there that he married,
wedding, by one of those strokes of fortune which
are the rule among the Corps des Mines, the
daughter of the rich owner of a spinning factory
at Arras. For fifteen years they lived in the
same small provincial town, and no event broke the
monotony of existence, not even the birth of a
child. An increasing irritation detached Madame
Hennebeau, who had been brought up to respect
money, and was disdainful of this husband who
gained a small salary with such difficulty, and
who enabled her to gratify none of the
satisfactions of vanity which she had dreamed of
at school. He was a man of strict honesty, who
never speculated, but stood at his post like a
soldier. The lack of harmony had only increased,
aggravated by one of those curious
misunderstandings of the flesh which freeze the
most ardent; he adored his wife, she had the
sensuality of a greedy blonde, and already they
slept apart, ill at ease and wounded. From that
time she had a lover of whom he was ignorant. At
last he left the Pas-de-Calais to occupy a
situation in an office at Paris, with the idea
that she would be grateful to him. But Paris only
completed their separation, that Paris which she
had desired since her first doll, and where she
washed away her provincialism in a week, becoming
a woman of fashion at once, and throwing herself
into all the luxurious follies of the period. The
ten years which she spent there were filled by a
great passion, a public intrigue with a man whose
desertion nearly killed her. This time the
husband had not been able to keep his ignorance,
and after some abominable scenes he resigned
himself, disarmed by the quiet unconsciousness of
this woman who took her happiness where she found
it. It was after the rupture, and when he saw
that she was ill with grief, that he had accepted
the management of the Montsou mines, still hoping
also that she would reform down there in that
desolate black country.
The Hennebeaus, since they had lived at Montsou,
returned to the irritated boredom of their early
married days. At first she seemed consoled by the
great quiet, soothed by the flat monotony of the
immense plain; she buried herself in it as a woman
who has done with the world; she affected a dead
heart, so detached from life that she did not even
mind growing stout. Then, beneath this
indifference a final fever declared itself, the
need to live once more, and she deluded herself
for six months by organizing and furnishing to her
taste the little villa belonging to the
management. She said it was frightful, and filled
it with upholstery, bric-a-brac, and all sorts of
artistic luxuries which were talked of as far as
Lille. Now the country exasperated her, those
stupid fields spread out to infinity, those
eternal black roads without a tree, swarming with
a horrid population which disgusted and frightened
her. Complaints of exile began; she accused her
husband of having sacrificed her to a salary of
forty thousand francs, a trifle which hardly
sufficed to keep the house up. Why could he not
imitate others, demand a part for himself, obtain
shares, succeed in something at last? And she
insisted with the cruelty of an heiress who had
brought her own fortune. He, always restrained,
and taking refuge in the deceptive coldness of a
man of business, was torn by desire for this
creature, one of those late desires which are so
violent and which increase with age. He had never
possessed her as a lover; he was haunted by a
continual image, to have her once to himself as
she had given herself to another. Every morning
he dreamed of winning her in the evening; then,
when she looked at him with her cold eyes, and
when he felt that everything within her denied
itself to him, he even avoided touching her hand.
It was a suffering without possible cure, hidden
beneath the stiffness of his attitude, the
suffering of a tender nature in secret anguish at
the lack of domestic happiness. At the end of six
months, when the house, being definitely
furnished, no longer occupied Madame Hennebeau,
she fell into the languor of boredom, a victim who
was being killed by exile, and who said that she
was glad to die of it.
Just then Paul Négrel arrived at Montsou.
His mother, the widow of a Provencal captain,
living at Avignon on a slender income, had had to
content herself with bread and water to enable him
to reach the École Polytechnique. He had
come out low in rank, and his uncle, M. Hennebeau,
had enabled him to leave by offering to take him
as engineer at the Voreux. From that time he was
treated as one of the family; he even had his room
there, his meals there, lived there, and was thus
enabled to send to his mother half his salary of
three thousand francs. To disguise this kindness
M. Hennebeau spoke of the embarrassment to a young
man of setting up a household in one of those
little villas reserved for the mine engineers,
Madame Hennebeau had at once taken the part of a
good aunt, treating her nephew with familiarity
and watching over his comfort. During the first
months, especially, she exhibited an overwhelming
maternity with her advice regarding the smallest
subjects. But she remained a woman, however, and
slid into personal confidences. This lad, so
young and so practical, with his unscrupulous
intelligence, professing a philosopher's theory of
love, amused her with the vivacity of the
pessimism which had sharpened his thin face and
pointed nose. One evening he naturally found
himself in her arms, and she seemed to give
herself up out of kindness, while saying to him
that she had no heart left, and wished only to be
his friend. In fact, she was not jealous; she
joked him about the putters, whom he declared to
be abominable, and she almost sulked because he
had no young man's pranks to narrate to her. Then
she was carried away by the idea of getting him
married; she dreamed of sacrificing herself and of
finding a rich girl for him. Their relations
continued a plaything, a recreation, in which she
felt the last tenderness of a lazy woman who had
done with the world.
Two years had passed by. One night M. Hennebeau
had a suspicion when he heard naked feet passing
his door. But this new adventure revolted him, in
his own house, between this mother and this son!
And besides, on the following day his wife spoke
to him about the choice of Cécile
Grégoire which she had made for her nephew.
She occupied herself over this marriage with such
ardour that he blushed at his own monstrous
imagination. He only felt gratitude towards the
young man who, since his arrival, had made the
house less melancholy.
As he came down from the dressing-room, M.
Hennebeau found that Paul, who had just returned,
was in the vestibule. He seemed to be quite
amused by the story of this strike.
"Well?" asked his uncle.
"Well, I've been round the settlements. They
seem to be quite sensible in there. I think they
will first send you a deputation."
But at that moment Madame Hennebeau's voice called
from the first story:
"Is that you, Paul? Come up, then, and tell
me the news. How queer they are to make such a
fuss, these people who are so happy!"
And the manager had to renounce further
information, since his wife had taken his
messenger. He returned and sat before his desk,
on which a new packet of dispatches was placed.
At eleven o'clock the Grégoires arrived,
and were astonished when Hippolyte, the footman,
who was placed as sentinel, hustled them in after
an anxious glance at the two ends of the road.
The drawing-room curtains were drawn, and they
were taken at once into the study, where M.
Hennebeau apologized for their reception; but the
drawing-room looked over the street and it was
undesirable to seem to offer provocations.
"What! you don't know?" he went on,
seeing their surprise.
M. Grégoire, when he heard that the strike
had at last broken out, shrugged his shoulders in
his placid way. Bah! it would be nothing, the
people were honest. With a movement of her chin,
Madame Grégoire approved his confidence in
the everlasting resignation of the colliers; while
Cécile, who was very cheerful that day,
feeling that she looked well in her capuchin cloth
costume, smiled at the word "strike,"
which reminded her of visits to the settlements
and the distribution of charities.
Madame Hennebeau now appeared in black silk,
followed by Négrel.
"Ah! isn't it annoying!" she said, at
the door. "As if they couldn't wait, those
men! You know that Paul refuses to take us to
Saint-Thomas."
"We can stay here," said M.
Grégoire, obligingly. "We shall be
quite pleased."
Paul had contented himself with formally saluting
Cécile and her mother. Angry at this lack
of demonstrativeness, his aunt sent him with a
look to the young girl; and when she heard them
laughing together she enveloped them in a maternal
glance.
Meanwhile, M. Hennebeau finished reading his
dispatches and prepared a few replies. They
talked near him; his wife explained that she had
not done anything to this study, which, in fact,
retained its faded old red paper, its heavy
mahogany furniture, its cardboard files, scratched
by use. Three-quarters of an hour passed and they
were about to seat themselves at table when the
footman announced M. Deneulin. He entered in an
excited way and bowed to Madame Hennebeau.
"Ah! you here!" he said, seeing the
Grégoires.
And he quickly spoke to the manager:
"It has come, then? I've just heard of it
through my engineer. With me, all the men went
down this morning. But the thing may spread. I'm
not at all at ease. How is it with you?"
He had arrived on horseback, and his anxiety
betrayed itself in his loud speech and abrupt
gestures, which made him resemble a retired
cavalry officer.
M. Hennebeau was beginning to inform him regarding
the precise situation, when Hippolyte opened the
dining-room door. Then he interrupted himself to
say:
"Lunch with us. I will tell you more at
dessert."
"Yes, as you please," replied Deneulin,
so full of his thoughts that he accepted without
ceremony.
He was, however, conscious of his impoliteness and
turned towards Madame Hennebeau with apologies.
She was very charming, however. When she had had
a seventh plate laid she placed her guests: Madame
Grégoire and Cécile by her husband,
then M. Grégoire and Deneulin at her own
right and left; then Paul, whom she put between
the young girl and her father. As they attacked
the hors-d'oeuvre she said, with a smile:
"You must excuse me; I wanted to give you
oysters. On Monday, you know, there was an
arrival of Ostend oysters at Marchiennes, and I
meant to send the cook with the carriage. But she
was afraid of being stoned----"
They all interrupted her with a great burst of
gaiety. They thought the story very funny.
"Hush!" said M. Hennebeau, vexed,
looking at the window, through which the road
could be seen. "We need not tell the whole
country that we have company this morning."
"Well, here is a slice of sausage which they
shan't have," M. Grégoire declared.
The laughter began again, but with greater
restraint. Each guest made himself comfortable,
in this room upholstered with Flemish tapestry and
furnished with old oak chests. The silver shone
behind the panes of the sideboards; and there was
a large hanging lamp of red copper, whose polished
rotundities reflected a palm and an aspidistra
growing in majolica pots. Outside, the December
day was frozen by a keen north-east wind. But not
a breath of it entered; a greenhouse warmth
developed the delicate odour of the pineapple,
sliced in a crystal bowl.
"Suppose we were to draw the curtains,"
proposed Négrel, who was amused at the idea
of frightening the Grégoires.
The housemaid, who was helping the footman,
treated this as an order and went and closed one
of the curtains. This led to interminable jokes:
not a glass or a plate could be put down without
precaution; every dish was hailed as a waif
escaped from the pillage in a conquered town; and
behind this forced gaiety there was a certain fear
which betrayed itself in involuntary glances
towards the road, as though a band of starvelings
were watching the table from outside.
After the scrambled eggs with truffles, trout came
on. The conversation then turned to the
industrial crisis, which had become aggravated
during the last eighteen months.
"It was inevitable," said Deneulin,
"the excessive prosperity of recent years was
bound to bring us to it. Think of the enormous
capital which has been sunk, the railways,
harbours, and canals, all the money buried in the
maddest speculations. Among us alone sugar works
have been set up as if the department could
furnish three beetroot harvests. Good heavens!
and to-day money is scarce, and we have to wait to
catch up the interest of the expended millions; so
there is a mortal congestion and a final
stagnation of business."
M. Hennebeau disputed this theory, but he agreed
that the fortunate years had spoilt the men.
"When I think," he exclaimed, "that
these chaps in our pits used to gain six francs a
day, double what they gain now! And they lived
well, too, and acquired luxurious tastes. To-day,
naturally, it seems hard to them to go back to
their old frugality."
"Monsieur Grégoire," interrupted
Madame Hennebeau, "let me persuade you, a
little more trout. They are delicious, are they
not?"
The manager went on:
"But, as a matter of fact, is it our fault?
We, too, are cruelly struck. Since the factories
have closed, one by one, we have had a deuce of a
difficulty in getting rid of our stock; and in
face of the growing reduction in demand we have
been forced to lower our net prices. It is just
this that the men won't understand."
There was silence. The footman presented roast
partridge, while the housemaid began to pour out
Chambertin for the guests.
"There has been a famine in India," said
Deneulin in a low voice, as though he were
speaking to himself. "America, by ceasing to
order iron, has struck a heavy blow at our
furnaces. Everything holds together; a distant
shock is enough to disturb the world. And the
empire, which was so proud of this hot fever of
industry!"
He attacked his partridge wing. Then, raising his
voice:
"The worst is that to lower the net prices we
ought logically to produce more; otherwise the
reduction bears on wages, and the worker is right
in saying that he has to pay the damage."
This confession, the outcome of his frankness,
raised a discussion. The ladies were not at all
interested. Besides, all were occupied with their
plates, in the first zest of appetite. When the
footman came back, he seemed about to speak, then
he hesitated.
"What is it?" asked M. Hennebeau.
"If there are letters, give them to me. I am
expecting replies."
"No, sir. It is Monsieur Dansaert, who is in
the hall. But he doesn't wish to disturb
you."
The manager excused himself, and had the head
captain brought in. The latter stood upright, a
few paces from the table, while all turned to look
at him, huge, out of breath with the news he was
bringing. The settlements were quiet; only it had
now been decided to send a deputation. It would,
perhaps, be there in a few minutes.
"Very well; thank you," said M.
Hennebeau. "I want a report morning and
evening, you understand."
And as soon as Dansaert had gone, they began to
joke again, and hastened to attack the Russian
salad, declaring that not a moment was to be lost
if they wished to finish it. The mirth was
unbounded when Négrel, having asked the
housemaid for bread, she replied, "Yes,
sir," in a voice as low and terrified as if
she had behind her a troop ready for murder and
rape.
"You may speak," said Madame Hennebeau
complacently. "They are not here yet."
The manager, who now received a packet of letters
and dispatches, wished to read one of his letters
aloud. It was from Pierron, who, in respectful
phrases, gave notice that he was obliged to go out
on strike with his comrades, in order to avoid
ill-treatment; and he added that he had not even
been able to avoid taking part in the deputation,
although he blamed that step.
"So much for liberty of work!" exclaimed
M. Hennebeau.
Then they returned to the strike, and asked him
his opinion.
"Oh!" he replied, "we have had them
before. It will be a week, or, at most, a
fortnight, of idleness, as it was last time. They
will go and wallow in the public-houses, and then,
when they are hungry, they will go back to the
pits."
Deneulin shook his head:
"I'm not so satisfied; this time they appear
to be better organized. Have they not a provident
fund?"
"Yes, scarcely three thousand francs. What
do you think they can do with that? I suspect a
man called Étienne Lantier of being their
leader. He is a good workman; it would vex me to
have to give him his certificate back, as we did
of old to the famous Rasseneur, who still poisons
the Voreux with his ideas and his beer. No
matter, in a week half the men will have gone
down, and in a fortnight the ten thousand will be
below."
He was convinced. His only anxiety was concerning
his own possible disgrace should the directors put
the responsibility of the strike on him. For some
time he had felt that he was diminishing in
favour. So leaving the spoonful of Russian salad
which he had taken, he read over again the
dispatches received from Paris, endeavouring to
penetrate every word. His guests excused him; the
meal was becoming a military lunch, eaten on the
field of battle before the first shots were fired.
The ladies then joined in the conversation.
Madame Grégoire expressed pity for the poor
people who would suffer from hunger; and
Cécile was already making plans for
distributing gifts of bread and meat. But Madame
Hennebeau was astonished at hearing of the
wretchedness of the Montsou colliers. Were they
not very fortunate? People who were lodged and
warmed and cared for at the expense of the
Company! In her indifference for the herd, she
only knew the lessons she had learnt, and with
which she had surprised the Parisians who came on
a visit. She believed them at last, and was
indignant at the ingratitude of the people.
Négrel, meanwhile, continued to frighten M.
Grégoire. Cécile did not displease
him, and he was quite willing to marry her to be
agreeable to his aunt, but he showed no amorous
fever; like a youth of experience, who, he said,
was not easily carried away now. He professed to
be a Republican, which did not prevent him from
treating his men with extreme severity, or from
making fun of them in the company of the ladies.
"Nor have I my uncle's optimism,
either," he continued. "I fear there
will be serious disturbances. So I should advise
you, Monsieur Grégoire, to lock up Piolame.
They may pillage you."
Just then, still retaining the smile which
illuminated his good-natured face, M.
Grégoire was going beyond his wife in
paternal sentiments with regard to the miners.
"Pillage me!" he cried, stupefied.
"And why pillage me?"
"Are you not a shareholder in Montsou! You
do nothing; you live on the work of others. In
fact you are an infamous capitalist, and that is
enough. You may be sure that if the revolution
triumphs, it will force you to restore your
fortune as stolen money."
At once he lost his childlike tranquillity, his
serene unconsciousness. He stammered:
"Stolen money, my fortune! Did not my
great-grandfather gain, and hardly, too, the sum
originally invested? Have we not run all the
risks of the enterprise, and do I today make a bad
use of my income?" Madame Hennebeau, alarmed
at seeing the mother and daughter also white with
fear, hastened to intervene, saying:
"Paul is joking, my dear sir."
But M. Grégoire was carried out of himself.
As the servant was passing round the crayfish he
took three of them without knowing what he was
doing and began to break their claws with his
teeth.
"Ah! I don't say but what there are
shareholders who abuse their position. For
instance, I have been told that ministers have
received shares in Montsou for services rendered
to the Company. It is like a nobleman whom I will
not name, a duke, the biggest of our shareholders,
whose life is a scandal of prodigality, millions
thrown into the street on women, feasting, and
useless luxury. But we who live quietly, like
good citizens as we are, who do not speculate, who
are content to live wholesomely on what we have,
giving a part to the poor: Come, now! your men
must be mere brigands if they came and stole a pin
from us!"
Négrel himself had to calm him, though
amused at his anger. The crayfish were still
going round; the little crackling sound of their
carapaces could be heard, while the conversation
turned to politics, M. Grégoire, in spite
of everything and though still trembling, called
himself a Liberal and regretted Louis Philippe.
As for Deneulin, he was for a strong Government;
he declared that the emperor was gliding down the
slope of dangerous concessions.
"Remember '89," he said. "It was
the nobility who made the Revolution possible, by
their complicity and taste for philosophic
novelties. Very well! the middle class to-day
are playing the same silly game with their furious
Liberalism, their rage for destruction, their
flattery of the people. Yes, yes, you are
sharpening the teeth of the monster that will
devour us. It will devour us, rest assured!"
The ladies bade him be silent, and tried to change
the conversation by asking him news of his
daughters. Lucie was at Marchiennes, where she
was singing with a friend; Jeanne was painting an
old beggar's head. But he said these things in a
distracted way; he constantly looked at the
manager, who was absorbed in the reading of his
dispatches and forgetful of his guests. Behind
those thin leaves he felt Paris and the directors'
orders, which would decide the strike. At last he
could not help yielding to his preoccupation.
"Well, what are you going to do?" he
asked suddenly.
M. Hennebeau startled; then turned off the
question with a vague phrase.
"We shall see."
"No doubt you are solidly placed, you can
wait," Deneulin began to think aloud.
"But as for me, I shall be done for if the
strike reaches Vandame. I shall have reinstalled
Jean-Bart in vain; with a single pit, I can only
get along by constant production. Ah! I am not
in a very pleasant situation, I can assure
you!"
This involuntary confession seemed to strike M.
Hennebeau. He listened and a plan formed within
him: in case the strike turned out badly, why not
utilize it by letting things run down until his
neighbour was ruined, and then buy up his
concession at a low price? That would be the
surest way of regaining the good graces of the
directors, who for years had dreamed of possessing
Vandame.
"If Jean-Bart bothers you as much as
that," said he, laughing, "why don't
you give it up to us?"
But Deneulin was already regretting his
complaints. He exclaimed:
"Never, never!"
They were amused at his vigour and had already
forgotten the strike by the time the dessert
appeared. An apple-charlotte meringue was
overwhelmed with praise. Afterwards the ladies
discussed a recipe with respect to the pineapple
which was declared equally exquisite. The grapes
and pears completed their happy abandonment at the
end of this copious lunch. All talked excitedly
at the same time, while the servant poured out
Rhine wine in place of champagne which was looked
upon as commonplace.
And the marriage of Paul and Cécile
certainly made a forward step in the sympathy
produced by the dessert. His aunt had thrown such
urgent looks in his direction, that the young man
showed himself very amiable, and in his wheedling
way reconquered the Grégoires, who had been
cast down by his stories of pillage. For a moment
M. Hennebeau, seeing the close understanding
between his wife and his nephew, felt that
abominable suspicion again revive, as if in this
exchange of looks he had surprised a physical
contact. But again the idea of the marriage, made
here before his face, reassured him.
Hippolyte was serving the coffee when the
housemaid entered in a fright.
"Sir, sir, they are here!"
It was the delegates. Doors banged; a breath of
terror was passing through the neighbouring rooms.
Around the table the guests were looking at one
another with uneasy indecision. There was
silence. Then they tried to resume their jokes:
they pretended to put the rest of the sugar in
their pockets, and talked of hiding the plate.
But the manager remained grave; and the laughter
fell and their voices sank to a whisper, while the
heavy feet of the delegates who were being shown
in tramped over the carpet of the next room.
Madame Hennebeau said to her husband, lowering her
voice:
"I hope you will drink your coffee."
"Certainly," he replied. "Let them
wait."
He was nervous, listening to every sound, though
apparently occupied with his cup.
Paul and Cécile got up, and he made her
venture an eye to the keyhole. They were stifling
their laughter and talking in a low voice.
"Do you see them?"
"Yes, I see a big man and two small ones
behind."
"Haven't they ugly faces?"
"Not at all; they are very nice."
Suddenly M. Hennebeau left his chair, saying the
coffee was too hot and he would drink it
afterwards. As he went out he put a finger to his
lips to recommend prudence. They all sat down
again and remained at table in silence, no longer
daring to move, listening from afar with intent
ears jarred by these coarse male voices.